Cakes/Pies

Cakes/Pies

Check out our line of Carousel Cakes, Pies & more! This delicious company has been consumers' favorite since 1965. Their cakes & pies are particularly flavorsome and we've hand-selected their best products to carry in our shop. Our most popular item is the Chocolate Outrage Cake, the fudgiest cake you'll ever taste! Plus, its extra creamy chocolate frosting is absolutely to die for. A must-have at your next event!

*NEW FEATURE* Pre-Order ANY Carousel Specialty Cakes & Pies that we may not carry everyday in-store but can special order for you in one week's time!

Click Here to see our full selection of Carousel Cakes !

*We currently do not offer *shipping* on our cakes. For more information, call us at 973-625-0025. Thank you.

23 results
cookie dough cake
Tollhouse Cookie Pie
Oprah's Red Velvet Cake
Sold Out
Brownie Cheesecake
pumpkin cheesecake
New York Cheesecake
carrot spice cake
Original Drizzle Cake
oreo & cream cake
Sold Out
Sold Out
Sold Out
Sold Out
Sold Out
Sold Out
Sold Out
Sold Out
Sold Out