Bakery

Candy

Chocolate

DIY Kits

Gourmet Treats

Lollipops & Molds

DIY Chocolate Making Kits

Learn to make beautiful chocolate creations in the comfort of your home!

Click Here

NEW Hot Cocoa Bombs!

Introducing our brand new Hot Cocoa Bombs! Give us a call at the shop to special order yours today! (973)-625-0025.

Art & Stationery

Candles

Clothing & Accessories

Kitchen

Gift Bundles

Toys & Games

Papaya Gifts

Natural Life Gifts

Art & Stationery

Candles

Clothing & Accessories

Kitchen

Gift Bundles

Toys & Games

Natural Life Gifts

Papaya Gifts

Shop All Products

Showing 1–80 of 1008 results

Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel Chocolate Heart
$7.99 Select options
Teacup Chocolate Gift Set
$8.99 Select options
Teacup Chocolate Lollipop
$3.59 Select options
Basketball Chocolate Lollipop
$3.59 Select options
Football Helmet Chocolate Lollipop
$3.79 Select options
Football Chocolate Lollipop
$3.29 Select options
Baseball/Softball Player Chocolate Lollipop
$3.59 Select options
Chocolate Horse Head
$5.99 Select options
Elephant Chocolate Lollipop
$3.29 Select options
Paw Print Chocolate Lollipop
$3.59 Select options
Dalmatian Dog Chocolate Lollipop
$3.59 Select options
Mother Cat Chocolate Lollipop
$3.59 Select options
Safari Animal Chocolate Lollipop
$3.69 Select options
Baby Safari Animal Chocolate Lollipop
$3.29 Select options
Owl Chocolate Lollipop
$3.59 Select options
Mother’s Day Sweet Grazing Board
$51.99 Select options
Chocolate Perfume Bottle
$7.99 Select options
Happy Mother’s Day Chocolate Lollipop
$3.59 Select options
Grandmothers Are Special Chocolate Lollipop
$3.99 Select options
MOM Chocolate Lollipop
$3.99 Select options
Baby’s Christening Chocolate Lollipop
$3.29 Select options
Holy Communion Chocolate Lollipop
$3.29 Select options
Chocolate Bible (Girl Praying)
$4.99 Select options
Chocolate Bible (Boy Praying)
$4.99 Select options
Out of stock
Jumbo Chocolate Marshmallow Shamrock
$14.99 Select options
Chocolate Rainbow
$7.99 Select options
Assorted Gold Chocolate Coins
$4.99 – $17.00 Select options
Out of stock
Irish Saying Shamrock Chocolate Lollipop
$3.89 Select options
Out of stock
Shiny Shamrock Lollipop
$4.59 Select options
Out of stock
Heart Shaped Raviolis
$15.00 Read more
Out of stock
Homemade Vodka Sauce
$15.00 Read more
Out of stock
Mixed Berry Linzer Tart Heart Cookies
$9.99 Read more
Animal Alphabet 20pc. Puzzle
$8.99 Add to cart
Fire Truck 20pc. Puzzle
$8.99 Add to cart
Alphabet & Phonics
$13.99 Add to cart
Pre-School Animal Sounds Puzzle Pairs
$15.99 Add to cart
Rhyming Words
$17.99 Add to cart
Math Bingo
$18.99 Add to cart
Dragons Slips & Ladders
$21.99 Add to cart
Family Bingo Set
$24.99 Add to cart
Timber Tower Jenga
$9.99 Add to cart
Marbles
$10.99 Add to cart
Fishin’ Hole
$12.99 Add to cart
Light Up WhirlO®
$6.99 – $9.99 Select options
Light Up Terrarium Kit
$24.99 Add to cart
Rock Painting Kit
$19.99 Add to cart
Mega Gem Dig Kit
$24.99 Add to cart
Dig A Dozen Gem Blocks
$24.99 Add to cart
Clack Game
$17.99 Add to cart
Engine No. 9 Board Game
$19.99 Add to cart
Bear Down Game
$24.99 Add to cart
Junior Ranger Flyer & Activity Book
$11.99 Select options
Night Sky Flyer & Activity Book
$11.99 Add to cart
Animal Tracks Flyer & Activity Book
$11.99 Select options
Out of stock
Valentine Candy Kabobs
$4.29 Read more
Out of stock
Petite Heart Chocolate Truffle Gift Box
$7.99 Select options
Out of stock
Petite Heart Chocolate Assortment Gift Box
$7.99 Select options
Out of stock
Small Heart Chocolate Assortment Gift Box
$11.99 Select options
Out of stock
Small Heart Chocolate Truffle Gift Box
$11.99 Select options
Out of stock
Medium Heart Chocolate Truffle Gift Box
$16.99 Select options
Out of stock
Medium Heart Chocolate Assortment Gift Box
$16.99 Select options
Out of stock
Large Heart Chocolate Truffle Gift Box
$32.99 Select options
Out of stock
Large Heart Assortment Chocolate Gift Box
$32.99 Select options
Out of stock
Grand Heart Truffle Chocolate Gift Box
$44.99 Select options
Out of stock
Grand Heart Assortment Chocolate Gift Box
$44.99 Select options
Out of stock
3pc. Chocolate Dipped Valentine Fortune Cookies
$3.99 Read more
Out of stock
4 pc. Conversation Heart Assorted Chocolate Gift Box
$6.99 Read more
Dark Chocolate Snowcaps
$3.79 Add to cart
Chocolate Heart Smash Box filled w/ Valentine Delights
$34.99 Select options
Out of stock
Valentine Deluxe Candy Mix
$6.99 Read more
Out of stock
Cupid Corn
$3.59 Read more
Out of stock
Red Non-Pareil Mini White Chocolate Pretzels
$4.59 Read more
Out of stock
Valentine Jeweled Jelly Beans
$3.79 Read more
Out of stock
Conversation Hearts
$3.59 Read more
Out of stock
Petite Sour Gummy Hearts
$3.99 Read more
Out of stock
Red Non-Pareil Gummy Hearts
$3.79 Read more
Out of stock
Valentine Non-Pareil Gummy Hearts
$3.79 Read more
Out of stock
Rainbow Triple Heart Gummies
$3.79 Read more
Out of stock
Assorted Gummy Lips
$3.79 Read more
Out of stock
Valentine Mini Chocolate Pretzels
$6.99 Select options

Bakery

Candy

Chocolate

DIY Kits

Gourmet Treats

Lollipops & Molds

DIY Chocolate Making Kits

*NEW* Hot Cocoa Bombs!

Introducing our brand new Hot Cocoa Bombs! Give us a call at the shop to special order yours today! (973)-625-0025.

Hard Goods & More!

Art & Stationery

Candles

Clothing & Accessories

Kitchen

Gift Bundles

Toys & Games

Papaya Gifts

Natural Life Gifts

Art & Stationery

Candles

Clothing & Accessories

Kitchen

Gift Bundles

Toys & Games

Natural Life Gifts

Papaya Gifts

Shop All Products

Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel Chocolate Heart

Teacup Chocolate Gift Set

Teacup Chocolate Lollipop

Basketball Chocolate Lollipop

Football Helmet Chocolate Lollipop

Football Chocolate Lollipop

Baseball/Softball Player Chocolate Lollipop

Chocolate Horse Head

Elephant Chocolate Lollipop

Paw Print Chocolate Lollipop

Dalmatian Dog Chocolate Lollipop

Mother Cat Chocolate Lollipop

Safari Animal Chocolate Lollipop

Baby Safari Animal Chocolate Lollipop

Owl Chocolate Lollipop

Mother’s Day Sweet Grazing Board

Chocolate Perfume Bottle

Happy Mother’s Day Chocolate Lollipop

Grandmothers Are Special Chocolate Lollipop

MOM Chocolate Lollipop

Baby’s Christening Chocolate Lollipop

Holy Communion Chocolate Lollipop

Chocolate Bible (Girl Praying)

Chocolate Bible (Boy Praying)

Jumbo Chocolate Marshmallow Shamrock

Chocolate Rainbow

Assorted Gold Chocolate Coins

Irish Saying Shamrock Chocolate Lollipop

Shiny Shamrock Lollipop

Heart Shaped Raviolis

Homemade Vodka Sauce

Mixed Berry Linzer Tart Heart Cookies

Animal Alphabet 20pc. Puzzle

Fire Truck 20pc. Puzzle

Alphabet & Phonics

Pre-School Animal Sounds Puzzle Pairs

Rhyming Words

Math Bingo

Dragons Slips & Ladders

Family Bingo Set

Timber Tower Jenga

Marbles

Fishin’ Hole

Light Up WhirlO®

Light Up Terrarium Kit

Rock Painting Kit

Mega Gem Dig Kit

Dig A Dozen Gem Blocks

Clack Game

Engine No. 9 Board Game

Bear Down Game

Junior Ranger Flyer & Activity Book

Night Sky Flyer & Activity Book

NEW Hot Cocoa Bombs!